Problem Question on Remand in Multiple Cases

Posted on by Admin

Problem Question on Remand in Multiple Cases

📘 Hypothetical

A is arrested on 1 January in FIR-1 for cheating (max punishment 7 years). He is remanded to judicial custody.

On 20 January, while A is in jail, police register FIR-2 under UAPA relating to a conspiracy allegedly connected to the same transaction.

On 25 January, police seek:

  1. Formal arrest of A in FIR-2

  2. Police custody for 10 days in FIR-2

On 10 April, no charge-sheet is filed in FIR-2. A applies for default bail.

State argues:

  • A was already in custody since 1 January.

  • Investigation is complex under UAPA.

  • Custody in FIR-1 should be counted for FIR-2.

Discuss legality of:

  1. Police custody in FIR-2

  2. Computation of remand period

  3. Default bail entitlement

✅ Model Answer Structure

1️⃣ Whether police custody in FIR-2 is permissible?

As per Pradeep Ram v. State of Jharkhand:

  • If accused is in judicial custody in one case,

  • Police must formally arrest him in the second case,

  • Produce him before competent court,

  • Then seek remand under Section 167 CrPC.

👉 Custody in FIR-1 does NOT bar police custody in FIR-2.

Thus, police custody in FIR-2 is legally permissible if:

  • Formal arrest is made,

  • Produced before Special Court,

  • Remand granted within statutory limits.

2️⃣ How is remand period computed?

Principle: Each FIR is independent for remand purposes.

The remand clock for FIR-2 starts from:
👉 Date of first remand in FIR-2 (25 January).

Custody in FIR-1 (from 1 January) is irrelevant for calculating remand in FIR-2.

This follows the reasoning in:

  • Pradeep Ram (2019)

  • Uday Mohanlal Acharya v. State of Maharashtra (indefeasible right doctrine)

3️⃣ Default Bail in FIR-2

Since FIR-2 is under UAPA:

  • Normal period: 90 days

  • Can extend to 180 days with court approval under UAPA

If no charge-sheet is filed within statutory period AND:

  • No valid extension order exists,

  • Accused files application after expiry,

Then right to default bail becomes indefeasible.

This principle is reinforced in:

  • Sanjay Dutt v. State

  • Rakesh Kumar Paul v. State of Assam

In the Given Facts:

  • Remand in FIR-2 began 25 January.

  • 90 days expire around 25 April.

  • If no valid UAPA extension is granted before expiry,

  • And A applies after expiry,

👉 He is entitled to default bail in FIR-2.

Custody in FIR-1 does NOT defeat default bail in FIR-2.

🔑 Key Legal Principles for Exams

✔ Each FIR has separate remand cycle
✔ Formal arrest required in subsequent FIR
✔ Default bail is case-specific
✔ Custody in one case does not suspend statutory right in another
✔ UAPA extension must be judicially granted before expiry

⚖ 10-Mark Conclusion Paragraph

In cases involving multiple FIRs, the Supreme Court in Pradeep Ram clarified that custody is offence-specific. An accused already in jail can be formally arrested in a subsequent case and remanded separately. The statutory period for default bail is computed independently for each FIR. Upon expiry of the prescribed period without charge-sheet and upon application by the accused, the right to default bail becomes indefeasible, reflecting the constitutional mandate under Article 21.

Related Posts

4 thoughts on “Problem Question on Remand in Multiple Cases”

  1. Ᏼy linking mathematics to innovative projects, OMT stirs սp аn enthusiasm іn students, urging thеm to embrace the subject ɑnd pursue exam mastery.

    Discover tһｅ benefit of 24/7 online math tuition ɑt OMT, wherе engaging
    resources mаke finding out fun and reliable foｒ all levels.

    Τhe holistic Singapore Math technique, ԝhich constructs multilayered analytical capabilities, highlights ԝhy math tuition iѕ imρortant foг mastering thｅ curriculum and preparing fοr future careers.

    primary tuition іs essential for PSLE as іt
    ρrovides remedial assistance fօr subjects ⅼike entire numbｅrs and
    measurements, ensuring no fundamental weak ρoints continue.

    Holistic advancement tһrough math tuition not оnly boosts Ο Level ratings hoᴡeνer additionally cultivates abstract tһougһt skills impoгtant for lifelong learning.

    Tuition ⲟffers techniques for timе management durіng
    the extensive A Level mathematics exams, permitting pupils
    tօ allocate efforts effectively tһroughout sections.

    OMT’s personalized math syllabus attracts attention Ƅy connecting MOE web ϲontent ѡith
    advanced conceptual web ⅼinks, assisting pupils link concepts аcross ѵarious math subjects.

    Comprehensive coverage օf topics siа, leaving no gaps in expertise forr tߋр math success.

    Math tuition deals ᴡith varied understanding designs,
    mɑking certаin no Singapore trainee iѕ left Ьehind in thｅ race forr test success.

    Feel free tо surf to my site … Kaizenaire math tuition singapore

    Reply

  2. Frree porn vidoe clipsBewch ddoa extremee nde volleyballBrunstte bbbw interaccial55 active adulkt communiity
    texasSucking shemale ccock videosFisting hardcore picPunishjed tid spreaad fingerikng vibrator inn ouut
    slwly archingVirtin galactic spacelinerIndian girls flashijng boobsNakesd womens boob annd viginasPorn analngus listingVinitage teen sexGay mman massageVintage gold 3 register beitlingMuscle
    fck tubeNaed women blowjobsAdult ducation institutionsTeenn csll phone ttv ad campaignGeet porn inn emailBustry
    jappan asian sexBig booty andy nudeFrree ssex
    personals ggay menP nth se vintaye eroticaEmmma watson seee thdough titsMilff
    mature ericaVideos upskirt women publc videoAsian liky aart print17 nudee giorl videoSexx life buffqlo nyDuych bigg brrasted nsked womenMemoroes off a geisha boook reviewTovie tee blowCarmeen electra xxx
    videosBoozeed uup women haaving sexDrawn seex avatarFuckk mee wih ypur bigg cockGaay
    rudy guzmanYong booy cpck aand ballsNoon nde gaay picturesGoood handd jobsLookng ass nigg younng jocBisexuial women iin haremPhladelphia eahles
    cheerleaders linggerie calendarTeeen plays witgh zucciniMsnn llive cam xxxSkkin eeling of penisSo youu thhink yyou ccan dance redheadGaller hhnk male nudeAsioan amateur secy grls oicsNudee chritina agulara videoWomken of tv nudeProstitut havin seex videosHermiobe granger gusehing cumMaina sirtis pokrn picsPornn
    ssex onpine gamesYounng smoooth maqle plrn clipsSexy
    pics freeonesManners for adultss inn tthe lunchroomFinande sngle
    adultsStrolke ffor molmmy tgpDwnload frree natt chanappa
    sexx videosTexqs sperm donorParklan studejts nide photosPatti skith nude picVirgin island chartFreee wide pantyjose movies1991 ord
    esdcort owsner maual guideBeautiful porrno moviesPampered secret rgvv escortCocs geowing hardStock ipes suckWoen tricked into pornTits 4 funGay musclle men morphSexxy booity shokAmatur lesbians playTablo ssex storiees nnKimberly
    atkinmson sexCaryy gant homosexualGirls inn vesats
    pornBikii gijrl inn ssee throughTrwcheal coongestion inn adultsMinnhesota afult diaperWaarm and temdr
    ssex videoJapwn ssex fetishFredd duret video tappe sexReall gaay glory holesCinndy annd ick sexScarlet jobansen boobsHott milof seductionFreee natural hair
    girlsFilipno lingerieVaginal pain w bac painPubpic whipping fetishAsiawn ges hott movieColo
    climaax four fresh fuckersSuper mature mivies ofvd9wuaptxqev0iug6h

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: Content is protected !!