MASTER CRIMINAL PROCEDURE & EVIDENCE CASE LAW TABLE

Posted on by Admin

⚖ MASTER CRIMINAL PROCEDURE & EVIDENCE CASE LAW TABLE

🔹 1. Muddamal / Property Release (Prohibition & General Law)

No Issue Case Citation Principle / Ratio
1 Muddamal release – vehicle / property Harsh Rameshbhai Lashkari v. State of Gujarat 18-08-2025 Where quantity exceeded statutory limit (20 litres), trial court’s refusal to release muddamal was upheld. No error committed.
2 General power of release of property Sunderbhai Ambalal Desai v. State of Gujarat (2002) 10 SCC 283 Courts should release seized property promptly under Sections 451/457 CrPC to avoid deterioration.
3 Cannot bypass CrPC by writ Khengarbhai Lakhabhai Dambhala v. State of Gujarat — When CrPC provides remedy for custody/disposal, writ under Art. 226 not maintainable.

🔹 2. Applicability of New Law (IPC → BNS)

Issue Case Principle
Offences committed before 01-07-2024 Vijay Sharma v. State of Rajasthan Offences committed prior to BNS enforcement must be dealt with under IPC. Pending inquiry/trial/appeal governed by old law.

🔹 3. Addition of Section in FIR / Charge

Issue Case Principle
Magistrate must give reasons Bhanubhai Mafatbhai Bharwad v. State of Gujarat Magistrate must record brief reasons while accepting addition of graver offence. “Kept with FIR” is not sufficient.
Same principle reiterated Sureshkumar Taraji Marwadi v. State of Gujarat Mechanical acceptance of addition report impermissible.

🔹 4. Re-Arrest After Addition of Graver Offence

Issue Case Principle
Re-arrest after addition Pradeep Ram v. State of Jharkhand Police cannot automatically arrest accused already on bail. Must seek cancellation under Sec 437(5)/439(2) CrPC.

🔹 5. Deletion of Section

Issue Case Principle
Deletion procedure Jagdish Nathabhai Solanki v. State of Gujarat IO cannot simply “delete” section and keep report with FIR. Must file charge-sheet or summary report; complainant must be heard.

🔹 6. Section 156(3) CrPC / 175(3) BNSS

Issue Case Principle
Affidavit mandatory Priyanka Srivastava v. State of U.P. 156(3) application must be supported by affidavit.
BNSS 175(3) safeguards Om Prakash Ambedkar v. State of Maharashtra Magistrate must consider SP representation + conduct inquiry before directing investigation.
Odisha view Swarnalata Jena v. State of Odisha Reasoned order mandatory before directing investigation.

🔹 7. Discharge Stage

Issue Case Principle
No mini trial State of Orissa v. Debendra Nath Padhi At Sec 227 stage, accused cannot produce defence material. Court considers only prosecution material.

🔹 8. NDPS – Release of Vehicle

Issue Case Principle
Interim vehicle release Bishwajit Dey v. State of Assam In absence of bar, Sections 451/457 CrPC applicable even in NDPS matters.

🔹 9. Private Complaint – Cognizance & Summons

Issue Case Principle
Satisfaction required Sachin Garg v. State of U.P. Magistrate must record prima facie satisfaction before issuing summons.
Non-mechanical order Pepsi Foods Ltd. v. Special Judicial Magistrate Summoning is serious matter; application of mind required.
Composite order permissible Amresh Kumar Dhiraj v. State of Jharkhand Cognizance + process may be composite but must reflect application of mind.

🔹 10. BNSS Section 223 (Private Complaint Procedure)

Issue Case Principle
Hearing accused before cognizance Basanagouda R. Patil v. Shivananda S. Patil Verification first, then notice, then cognizance.
Same clarified Sashidhar Jagdishan v. State of Maharashtra Accused to be heard before cognizance, not before verification.

🔹 11. Meaning of Cognizance

Case Principle
Tula Ram v. Kishore Singh Cognizance = Judicial application of mind to facts for proceeding.

🔹 12. Section 35 BNSS (Notice Before Arrest)

Case Principle
Satender Kumar Antil v. CBI Non-compliance with notice does not automatically mandate arrest. Arrest is last resort.
Vijay Pal Yadav v. Mamta Singh Checklist under Arnesh Kumar must not be mechanical. Magistrate must apply mind.

🔹 13. Production Without Arrest

Case Principle
Siddharth v. State of U.P. Section 170 does not mandate arrest before filing charge-sheet.

🔹 14. Grounds of Arrest

Case Principle
Prabir Purkayastha v. State (NCT of Delhi) Distinction between “reasons” and “grounds” of arrest. Grounds must be communicated.
Mihir Rajesh Shah v. State of Maharashtra Grounds of arrest mandatory under Articles 21 & 22(1).
State of Karnataka v. Sri Darshan Mere absence of written grounds not ipso facto illegal unless prejudice shown.

🔹 15. Default Bail

Case Principle
Enforcement Directorate v. Kapil Wadhawan 60/90 days counted from first remand order.
Rakesh Kumar Paul v. State of Assam 60 days if minimum punishment <10 years.

🔹 16. Further Investigation

Case Principle
K. Chandrasekhar v. State of Kerala Further investigation ≠ fresh investigation.
Vinubhai Haribhai Malaviya v. State of Gujarat Magistrate can order further investigation even after charge-sheet.
Jyoti Sanjiv Rajput v. State of Gujarat Magistrate cannot order de novo investigation.

🔹 17. Charge-sheet Completeness

Case Principle
Sharif Ahmed v. State of U.P. Charge-sheet complete if sufficient material exists to proceed.
Sameer Sandhir v. CBI Additional documents may be produced later with court permission.

🔹 18. NI Act

Case Principle
Rohitbhai Jivanlal Patel v. State of Gujarat Presumption under Section 139 NI Act is mandatory unless rebutted.

🔹 19. Improper Charge

Case Principle
Kalicharan v. State of U.P. Non-compliance of Sections 213 & 313 CrPC vitiates trial.

🔹 20. Section 319 CrPC

Case Principle
Sukhpal Singh Khaira v. State of Punjab Strong and cogent evidence required to summon additional accused.

🔹 21. Primary & Secondary Evidence

Case Principle
Sardar Sarovar Narmada Nigam Ltd. v. Rupdevsingh Secondary evidence admissible only after foundational facts proved.

⚖ ADDITIONAL LANDMARK JUDGMENTS TABLE

(Advanced Judicial Reference Sheet)

🔹 1. FIR – Registration Mandatory

Issue Case Citation Principle
Mandatory registration of FIR Lalita Kumari v. Government of Uttar Pradesh (2014) 2 SCC 1 Registration of FIR is mandatory if information discloses cognizable offence. Preliminary inquiry permissible only in limited categories.

🔹 2. Delay in FIR

Issue Case Principle
Delay not always fatal State of Himachal Pradesh v. Gian Chand Delay must be explained; not automatically fatal to prosecution.

🔹 3. Multiple FIRs

Issue Case Principle
Second FIR barred T.T. Antony v. State of Kerala Second FIR on same occurrence not maintainable.
Counter FIR allowed Upkar Singh v. Ved Prakash Counter complaint by opposite party permissible.

🔹 4. Arrest Guidelines

Issue Case Principle
Arrest safeguards Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar Police must follow Section 41 checklist before arrest in offences punishable up to 7 years.
DK Basu guidelines D.K. Basu v. State of West Bengal Mandatory arrest memo and safeguards against custodial torture.

🔹 5. Anticipatory Bail

Issue Case Principle
No time limit unless specified Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) Anticipatory bail ordinarily continues till trial unless limited by court.
Parameters Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia v. State of Punjab Anticipatory bail to be granted based on judicial discretion; no rigid formula.

🔹 6. Regular Bail Principles

Issue Case Principle
Bail is rule State of Rajasthan v. Balchand “Bail is rule, jail is exception.”
Triple test P. Chidambaram v. Directorate of Enforcement Flight risk, tampering with evidence, influencing witnesses.

🔹 7. Quashing under Section 482 CrPC

Issue Case Principle
Categories for quashing State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal Seven illustrative categories for quashing FIR.
Compromise quashing Gian Singh v. State of Punjab High Court may quash non-compoundable offences if dispute is private and no societal impact.
Serious offences cannot be quashed Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab Heinous offences affecting society cannot be quashed on compromise.

🔹 8. Framing of Charge

Issue Case Principle
Strong suspicion sufficient Union of India v. Prafulla Kumar Samal At charge stage, court sees whether strong suspicion exists.
No meticulous evaluation Amit Kapoor v. Ramesh Chander Court should not conduct mini trial at charge stage.

🔹 9. Confession

Issue Case Principle
Extra-judicial confession Sahadevan v. State of Tamil Nadu Can be basis of conviction if voluntary and trustworthy.
Section 27 Evidence Act Pulukuri Kottaya v. Emperor Only discovery portion of confession admissible.

🔹 10. Dying Declaration

Issue Case Principle
Sole basis of conviction Khushal Rao v. State of Bombay Reliable dying declaration can sustain conviction without corroboration.
No absolute rule of doctor certification Laxman v. State of Maharashtra Medical certification desirable but not mandatory if evidence shows fitness.

🔹 11. Hostile Witness

Issue Case Principle
Evidence not wiped out State of U.P. v. Ramesh Prasad Misra Testimony of hostile witness not completely rejected; reliable portion may be relied upon.

🔹 12. Test Identification Parade (TIP)

Issue Case Principle
TIP not substantive evidence Budhsen v. State of U.P. TIP is corroborative; identification in court is substantive evidence.

🔹 13. Circumstantial Evidence

Issue Case Principle
Five golden principles Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra Chain must be complete; hypothesis consistent only with guilt.

🔹 14. Benefit of Doubt

Issue Case Principle
Suspicion vs proof Kali Ram v. State of Himachal Pradesh If two views possible, one favouring accused must be adopted.

🔹 15. Electronic Evidence

Issue Case Principle
65B certificate mandatory Anvar P.V. v. P.K. Basheer Electronic record admissible only with 65B certificate.
Clarification Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal 65B certificate mandatory unless original device produced.

Related Posts

23 thoughts on “MASTER CRIMINAL PROCEDURE & EVIDENCE CASE LAW TABLE”

  1. Staff are friendly and welcoming, adding to the laid-back atmosphere.
    The place is quite spacious, with plenty of tables
    and cozy side seating. Irish Murphy’s is an easy-to-access public bar
    in central Brisbane at the business area, George Street, offering a
    classic Irish vibe with live music on select days.
    The wooden decor and extensive collection of Irish knick-knacks create an authentic atmosphere reminiscent of Dublin.
    You can also play a variety of table games, such as blackjack, roulette, baccarat, craps, and poker,
    with friendly and professional dealers. The casino features
    over 1,300 gaming machines, including the latest
    pokies, video poker, and electronic table games. In this article, we will provide you with a
    comprehensive and unbiased guide to this amazing entertainment destination, covering everything you need to know before you
    visit. Are you looking for a place to have fun, relax, and indulge in Brisbane?
    Slot machines, poker tables, and electronic games provide for all-around entertainment satisfaction, the
    most popular engagements being Blackjack, Texas Hold’em, and Treasury 21.

    143 luxuriously appointed suites feature all the comforts you could ask for,
    while an abundance of premium food and beverage
    options will leave you spoilt for choice.
    But the base game grind kept me in the game for two hours.
    Two hundred bucks a night, but it’s a studio with a kitchenette, full-size fridge, and a bed that
    doesn’t feel like a folding table. It’s not fancy,
    but it’s quiet. But it’s there. No forced fun.
    But at the end of the day, only 405 was refunded.

    Joy stated 3 times that she was going to refund me 410.
    I questioned how she came out with the figure, she gave me random calculations of
    which was never disclosed on the agreement and randomly appeared.

    Claiming that she was only able to refund me 410 out of the 900 I
    paid. Joy told me to read the agreement re refunds when I requested the opt out.
    I recommend Love88 for those looking to find their special lady.
    Joy’s professional match making service is amazing.

    When staying at Adina Apartment Hotel Brisbane, you can explore all the city
    has to offer and then return to the comfort of your hotel where there is a
    swimming pool, fitness center, restaurant and…
    Offering a fitness center and a garden, Centre CBD
    – Pool Spa Gym – Water View – Sleep 4 in Brisbane is close to Brisbane Central
    Station and Queen Street Mall. Pullman Brisbane King George Square is opposite City Hall, and features extremely spacious rooms.

    Breathe in Brisbane’s casino’s atmosphere, where every turn surprises you, every moment thrills you, and every win gratifies you.
    So, if you love your food as much as you love your games, Brisbane won’t disappoint you.
    Can you conjure up the thrill of dice rolling, poker cards shuffling or the melodious clang of a
    slot machine hitting the jackpot? Do you ever wonder what
    makes a leisurely evening buzz with excitement?

    Sun Princess Casino — where sophistication meets fun under the ever-shining sun! Our curated list features the city’s top casinos,
    promising you a world of gaming fun, nightlife, and luxury.

    The agency is known for customizing matches and closely following up on each case, providing a high level of service that has earned them glowing reviews.
    Love88 Introduction Agency Pty Ltd offers a unique and personalized approach to matchmaking, with the founder Joy being described as cheerful and responsible.

    There is one Indian lady at security, she will throughly scrutinize all Indian/ Asian people with no valid reason as she believes
    that Indian/ Asians cheat.
    Designed to spark curiosity, Hotel Indigo Brisbane City Center brings it’s
    electric charm and hidden artistic flair to Brisbane City.
    The room was very spacious, clean, and the bed was comfortable.
    Location, comfort, staff, facilities, food Offering 312 spacious guest rooms,
    W Brisbane features three restaurants and bars, a spa and fitness center.
    Lounging by the pool all day ordering cocktails and food was heaven. The atmosphere and staff attentiveness was the best I have had at an Australian hotel.
    Location , staff responsiveness and courtesy, restaurant(Terrace) wine bar for outstanding selections and hours of operation.
    Why is the ALP ignoring the will of the people? The fact-checker on the abortion bill
    is amazingly obtuse. Humans caused my trauma but I’m still told
    to go be in emergency community housing despite the fact i cannot
    live with other people .. It’s clear those in power don’t care
    about people or animals. They prioritize luxury lifestyles over supporting disabled
    and poor people. Despite other priorities like the Olympics, he remains dedicated to addressing the needs of Queenslanders and managing taxpayer funds responsibly.

    References:
    Brisbane casino hotels

    Reply

  12. Book of Dead von Play’n GO gilt als moderne Variante von Book of Ra.
    Wird der Bonuscode fehlerhaft eingetragen oder vergessen,
    erfolgt keine Gutschrift. Das gilt sowohl für Freispiele als auch für Bonusgeld-Aktionen. Während ein Bonus aktiv ist,
    gilt ein Einsatzlimit von 5 € pro Runde oder Spin. Bei den regulären Einzahlungsboni wird keine konkrete zeitliche Frist genannt, in der die
    Umsatzanforderungen erfüllt sein müssen.
    Bei Kryptowährungen hängt die Ankunft im Ziel-Wallet von Netzwerk und interner Freigabe
    ab, häufig erfolgt die Gutschrift nach kurzer Pending-Phase.
    Teile uns deine Hinweise gerne mit unter Zusätzlich ist vor einer Auszahlung mindestens eine Einzahlung erforderlich,
    um die Authentifizierung im Rahmen der AML- und KYC-Richtlinien abzuschließen. Der maximal abhebbare Betrag liegt beim 10-Fachen des
    Werts der Free Spins, der 100 € entspricht. Die
    mit den Freispielen erzielten Gewinne müssen 45-mal umgesetzt werden, bevor eine Auszahlung möglich ist.
    Welche Umsatzbedingungen gelten für die Freispiele ohne
    Einzahlung? Einer Verifizierung werden die Free Spins
    automatisch deinem Konto gutgeschrieben.
    Häufig gelten Obergrenzen pro Spin oder pro Runde,
    und einzelne Spiele können ausgeschlossen sein. Der Bonus wird nach
    einer qualifizierenden Einzahlung automatisch gutgeschrieben. Es unterliegt nicht den spezifischen deutschen Regeln wie
    OASIS-Anbindung, 5-Sekunden-Regel oder dem 1-Euro-Slotlimit.

    Auszahlungszeiten werden transparent erklärt, inklusive
    Hinweis, dass die Geschwindigkeit methodenabhängig ist und meist zwischen 0 und 5 Banktagen liegt.
    Tagsüber erfolgt die Rückmeldung häufig binnen zwei Minuten, abends kann es
    zu leichten Verzögerungen kommen. Ein- und Auszahlungen sind mobil ebenso möglich,
    was für Nutzer, die primär am Smartphone spielen, ein klares Plus ist.
    Die Qualität des Streams, die Dealer-Performance und die
    Tischreaktion waren einwandfrei. Freispiele sind im Willkommenspaket enthalten und
    tauchen regelmäßig in saisonalen Aktionen auf.
    Nach erfolgreicher Anmeldung im Online Casino und der Verifizierung deines Accounts stehen sie dir automatisch zur
    Verfügung. Die 50 Freispiele ohne Einzahlung gelten für den Slot Book
    of Kemet von BGaming.
    Dafür ist eine Einzahlung von mindestens 80 € Echtgeld erforderlich.

    Im 1go Casino Bonus ohne Einzahlung Casino gibt es ein wöchentliches Cashback, bei
    dem bis zu 10 % der Nettoverluste automatisch rückerstattet werden. Pro Spin bekommst
    du einen Wert von 0,20 €, was bei 50 Freispielen einem
    Einsatzvolumen von 10 € entspricht.
    Nun ja, nicht ganz ohne – denn für die Auszahlung
    ist schließlich eben doch eine Einzahlung erforderlich.
    Mit den 50 Freispielen, die jedem neuen Kunden gratis offeriert werden, hebt sich dieses Casino klar
    von der Masse ab. Neben zahlreichen klassischen Slots stehen auch
    moderne Automaten mit Features wie Free Spins, Multiplikatoren und anderen Bonusspielen zur Verfügung.

    Für Freispiele ohne Einzahlung gelten etwas strengere Anforderungen – hier kannst du dich auf
    einen Rollover von etwa 45x einstellen. Diese Schwelle gilt oft auch für weitere Angebote wie Reloads im VIP Programm oder Freispiele für Bestandskunden.
    Um den Willkommensbonus im 1Go Casino zu aktivieren, ist eine Mindesteinzahlung von 20 € erforderlich.
    Wir haben dir hier einmal die wichtigsten Umsatzbedingungen für Einzahlungsboni im 1Go Casino zusammengefasst.
    Hier kannst du automatisch über qualifizierende Einsätze teilnehmen. Die Freispiele gelten in der Regel für bestimmte Top-Slots, die vom Anbieter vorgegeben werden.
    Auch hier gelten Bonusbedingungen, typischerweise Gültigkeit und Umsatzvorgaben für Freispielgewinne.
    Manche Bonusaktionen im 1Go Casino setzen die Eingabe eines Bonus Codes voraus.
    Bei Freispielen ohne Einzahlung erfolgt die Fristangabe häufig erst nach der Aktivierung und ist damit nicht im Vorfeld einsehbar.
    Der Aufstieg erfolgt automatisch basierend auf der
    Einzahlungshistorie. Die Gutschrift erfolgt nach der
    qualifizierenden Einzahlung und unterliegt einem 40-fachen Umsatz.
    Eine gesonderte Anmeldung zur Aktion ist nicht notwendig – die Gutschrift erfolgt
    automatisch.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: Content is protected !!