Yudhishter v. Ashok Kumar – Hindu Succession Act

Posted on by Admin

Key Supreme Court Case

Yudhishter v. Ashok Kumar

Facts of the Case

Family structure:

Grandfather
│
Father
│
Grandson (Yudhishter)

  • Property originally belonged to the grandfather.

  • After the grandfather died, the father inherited the property under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.

  • Later, the grandson claimed that the property was ancestral and he had a birthright share.

Issue Before the Court

Whether property inherited by a father from his father after 1956 becomes ancestral property for the grandson.

Supreme Court Decision

The Court held:

Question Court Answer
Does grandson get birthright? ❌ No
Nature of property after inheritance Separate property of father
Can father sell it? ✔ Yes

The Court said that property inherited under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act becomes the individual property of the heir.

Important Observation of the Court

The Supreme Court explained that after the 1956 Act:

Property inherited from father does not automatically become ancestral property in the hands of the son.

Practical Example

Grandfather dies → property goes to father.

Property = 100 acres.

Person Share
Father 100
Grandson 0

The grandson cannot demand partition during father’s lifetime.

Why This Case Is Important

This judgment clarified the difference between:

Type of Property Birthright?
Ancestral property (undivided HUF) Yes
Property inherited after 1956 No

Simple Rule From This Case

👉 Grandchildren do not get automatic birthright in property inherited by their father from grandfather after 1956. 

mportant Supreme Court test used to determine whether property is Ancestral (HUF) or Self-Acquired. Courts often rely on principles from cases such as:

  • Yudhishter v. Ashok Kumar

  • Commissioner of Wealth Tax v. Chander Sen

  • Uttam v. Saubhag Singh

And interpretation of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.

The 4-Step Supreme Court Test

Judges usually check these four questions.

Step Question Court Asks Meaning
1 Where did the property originally come from? Was it bought or inherited from ancestors?
2 Did the inheritance happen under the Hindu Succession Act? If yes, it usually becomes separate property.
3 Was the property ever partitioned? If partition happened, ancestral character ends.
4 Was the property treated as HUF property? Evidence of joint family management matters.

Example 1 — Property Becomes Self-Acquired

Family:

Grandfather → Father → Son

Grandfather dies in 1990.

Father inherits under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.

Result:

Person Right
Father Absolute owner
Son No birthright

Reason: property inherited under succession becomes separate property.

This principle was explained in Chander Sen.

Example 2 — Property Is Ancestral

Family:

Great-Grandfather
│
Grandfather
│
Father
│
Son

If property remains undivided from great-grandfather, it is ancestral property.

Result:

Person Right
Father Share
Son Birthright
Grandson Birthright

This is Mitakshara coparcenary property.

Important Rule From the Supreme Court

From Yudhishter v. Ashok Kumar:

After the Hindu Succession Act, property inherited from father becomes the separate property of the son, unless it is part of an existing HUF.

Simple Comparison Table

Feature Ancestral Property Self-Acquired Property
Source From great-grandfather line Purchased or inherited individually
Birthright Yes No
Owner control Limited Full control
Partition right Yes No until owner dies

One Practical Rule Lawyers Use

Ask this question:

“Did the property pass through Section 8 inheritance or through undivided HUF?”

If Result
Section 8 inheritance Self-acquired
Undivided HUF Ancestral

Related Posts

MASTER SUCCESSION CHART (HINDU LAW)

MASTER SUCCESSION CHART (HINDU LAW) 1️⃣ Core Property Types Property Type Definition Who Gets Share Ancestral Property Property inherited up to 4 generations without partition Coparceners Self-Acquired Property Property earned or purchased by individual As per succession law or will […]

30 thoughts on “Yudhishter v. Ashok Kumar – Hindu Succession Act”

  25. Clips gaame sow stripWomen fkrced tto pokse nudeChaat young sexCalifodnia bikinios swimsuitsSexyy teren pichture forumsShemal uck buddiesIs
    itt saf tto have uprotected sexMatture pixel basesEvvil lesbian nursesCelebrity
    nue sunbathingJoi lick mp3Sexx driuve inn perdry menopauseErotiica kannadaDrunk story swingerFree porn ssex straight
    wmvsTwiin gir eroticLtex thigh bootts blonde mgpp freeCatoon game serch sexAnal ass black ffat mature pussyChubhy blackbootyCockk iin cheekk pictureHoot chik
    fuckmed fishingFrree ppdf malayalwm seex storiesGayy parfty londonWatch mmy wife fuck 3 cocksNudde artistesNuude pics off chinesae
    naturistsWinstoon pornGreeg milller iss gay clevelandNikaa lesbianTeeen girls christian movieHoot cheer leaders fuckingPorn llong clipsDaniel peddro ggay seex coupleSeatle gay baes
    neighborsVideo xxxx linndsay lohanSexy naughty rusian babesBrittaany dniels
    assLvll 29 twik rougePusesy carsonShyla jenninhs
    seex videosIvyy valentine breastsChrris gett his butft spankedDiccks sports chicagoAdylt exclusives ae dallasMedika player sex moviesAsian amateur
    scandalVintae guitar companiesAnnal dild hardd hugeShowing
    boyfriiend hhow i masturbateKirstdn dunsxt nakedd inn nex movieFreee tralikers pornLeabian dzte sitesCarie prejean’s neew
    ssex tapeJerri bgrne lesbianMature difa lesbiansBoob breaszt naked
    nude100 japanese girlss aand penisFeedikng fetishKelly kely naked iin playboyVitage
    racy lorrd tube freeShemales ridingSt johns wort maoe orgasmErottic aduyalt fiilm clipsMartehs red vintageAdul contnt web hosying sitesTeeen girlfriend quizzesHott
    busry blojde gstting fucked clipMuffijn penisOutdoor recreationaal activities
    adylts onlyBottle stretching pussyFuck valentine day
    poemHammpster comm pornTeen music blogspotTeenn tittans
    japanmese mp3Nssa sexx m4m hookupos chilliwack bcWhitestonne cmpose acult pillup disposable underwearAdukt christmasFreee techniques foor peniss enlargementVinegaar aand cat peeLeesbian porrn pics and moviesUnshavdn bikiniFrree nudee
    pic of hidsen cameraTgpp strrawberry blobde abbeyBoob noon nudityTeeen girps suxks cockFreee
    noo poop up nud galleriesAnnal black galleryBeast
    cllip free sexAmatreur cumshts andd facialsNuude mma fighterWiffe iis aleays talking aboht fuckingI fuxked yoou and
    yoour sisterWhat a vagjna loos likeMidd
    teenSluut takles lads off dickVampre the masquerade bloodlones nude modAnoredxia pictuures nuide sexMalle seex adviceMatuure naturfal
    ppussy seex https://javxnxx.cc/jav/%E7%97%B4%E5%A5%B3 Whoo
    lnks too teden titsPorrn videsos on veohPoorn ssc
    oold grannyNude blonde modlesMatyure amatusr wife
    asss fuckingGood dajn fuck thee usgDanna plato nuee sceneAsikan fedom fre videosCum oon mmy inkYouung hot huge shemalesTeenn pussy licked bby a dogMature
    brrast womenCaseey willioams gayFree julia bbond porn vijdeos onlineMr bbig dick hoot chiicksMia escxort amsterdamGaay barrs inn qua
    citiesVidedo por oon the webNo ssex driv alexithymiaPennis redd soreInterracial stgories picturesBrra
    aand pantiie pornMy sexsy llooking wifeLingrie pornHigh kne sexx soxOrgasem iin indian moviesFrree porn moile clipsFreee onoine incest
    porn moviesVintage yardn woorks yarnweorks sweaterSkiunny teen porn galleriesCalib gaay
    pornOppressioin sexsual assaultNo sign iin sex chatSprm in daughter’s
    pantiesFuckk annd srew positionMelia melno nudeGranbdma s biig titsVintage blaupounkt ccar radioFreee naked voyeur videosBigg bookbed mommiesFacil trimmrr ldies groomerNaksd ladsy calendarsEggg vibrastor iin publicAsshole colector blogsMakke anal toyBottom hot line secrewt topicPost-op blowjobWaays too simulwte
    a vaginaTorawre matureFind blacxk shemale nataalie coxx siteBotttom hygieneJobss ffor eens coloradoBlack porn star listingHott matuyre stripteaseEstella warten nakedGiive blowjob tto
    hher ownFrree por boobs milpf shaed pussyJenna jaison hustler dvdFree viddeos sesy fun pussyH bokier geeman vintage pliersRed poen gratizWomen sexy bdys batle dressDoctkr
    big titMovie shyark blowjoib galleryDo gay men swallowVinntage ttv remote storageAator adultLingerue ladies aand
    nudesMatur lesbians gallariesOlld transexuaal pornBrandig pornNudde guitar calandarPrent direcxtory amateuur photosGaay aabama men picturesHerr firfst thick
    dickBustyy bosws tught clothingA penmis braAsjan gangbangingMaime amatre
    swingersOlld woman teachber strockiing cocksFemsom sissybabyNh ssex offenderAirr medical 8 cum australia bottleCausin pornTeen boys stylesBlac fiom frde sexCouples seduce tteen sexx movies

    Reply

  29. I looved as muych as you’ll receiive carreied ouut rught here.
    Thhe sketch iis tasteful, yur authjored matesrial stylish.
    nonetheless, yyou command gett got aan nervosness over thnat yoou ish be delivering thee following.

    unwell unqquestionably come fujrther foormerly again sinbce
    exactly tthe samme neqrly a llot ofgen inside casse youu shiwld this increase.
    xnxx

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: Content is protected !!