S. Kaladevi v. V. R. Somasundaram & Ors.

Posted on by Admin

S. Kaladevi v. V. R. Somasundaram & Ors.

📌 Court:

Supreme Court of India
Judgment dated: 12 April 2010

🔎 Background Facts

  • The dispute related to immovable property.

  • The plaintiff relied upon an unregistered sale deed to claim rights in the property.

  • The defendant objected to its admissibility under Section 49 of the Registration Act, 1908, arguing that since the document was compulsorily registrable but unregistered, it could not be received in evidence.

The core issue before the Supreme Court was:

❓ Whether an unregistered sale deed can be admitted in evidence for any purpose?

⚖️ Legal Issues

  1. Whether an unregistered sale deed affecting immovable property can be admitted in evidence?

  2. Whether such document can be used for collateral purposes?

  3. Scope of proviso to Section 49 of the Registration Act.

📖 Statutory Provisions Involved

  • Section 17, Registration Act, 1908 – Compulsory registration of documents.

  • Section 49, Registration Act, 1908 – Effect of non-registration.

  • Proviso to Section 49 – Permits use of unregistered document for collateral purposes.

  • Section 53A, Transfer of Property Act (incidentally relevant).

🧑‍⚖️ Supreme Court Holding

The Supreme Court held:

✅ 1. General Rule:

An unregistered sale deed affecting immovable property cannot:

  • Confer title

  • Create interest in property

  • Be admitted as evidence of ownership

✅ 2. Important Exception (Proviso to Section 49):

Such a document can be admitted in evidence for collateral purposes.

🎯 What is “Collateral Purpose”?

Collateral purpose means:

  • A purpose other than proving transfer of title

  • Something incidental or secondary

Examples:

  • Nature of possession

  • Character of entry

  • Date of transaction

  • Evidence in suit for specific performance

But ❌ Not to prove ownership or complete transfer of property.

🧠 Core Ratio (In Nutshell)

🔹 An unregistered sale deed cannot convey title or prove ownership.
🔹 However, it is admissible in evidence for collateral purposes under the proviso to Section 49 of the Registration Act.
🔹 Courts must distinguish between proving title (not allowed) and proving collateral facts (allowed).

📊 Practical Trial Court Importance

Issue Position After This Case
Unregistered sale deed Not proof of title
Admissibility Yes, but limited
Collateral use Permissible
Specific performance suit Can be relied upon
Title declaration suit Cannot prove ownership

🔥 Why This Judgment is Important

  • Frequently cited in property disputes.

  • Clarifies confusion regarding admissibility vs evidentiary value.

  • Used in Order 7 Rule 11 and objection to exhibit cases.

  • Important in mutation, possession, and injunction matters.

📌 Exam-Oriented One-Line Ratio

“Unregistered sale deed is inadmissible to prove title but admissible for collateral purposes under proviso to Section 49 of the Registration Act.”

Related Posts

11 thoughts on “S. Kaladevi v. V. R. Somasundaram & Ors.”

  9. Simpply desire to saay yur artucle iis aas astounding.
    Thee clarity to you putt uup iis just exellent and i caan suppose yoou aare knowleedgeable iin this subject.
    Welll alpong wwith your permiossion leet mme too taake hold off yur eed tto kep uup too
    date ith impending post. Thank yoou a million annd pleasxe keepp upp the enjoyable work.
    ofvd9wuapti8n0l7sw8l

    Reply

  11. Brittany spers ffake nudesPornn indiansTodys r uss operating adhlt storesSnannoin weed nudeMy sex auntTurnhing a srraight mann gayAsizn paits uzed inn
    viruddh55 actfive adult communities downingtwn paFrree mzzo fortee
    hentaiPenis bioting videoStrip all noon alphanumeric charactersPorn guys tubeDarl modfel teenSllave gurl thumbsSexyy movie syars pnoto galleryHenai
    toyhs sexyFreee voyeur pronGoldxen showeers piiss linksTortuted fuckrd
    screamXxxx ccougars nylonsPanty ten skirtsJodie mash titsInterracial matuire lesbianMatue swallows compilaztion tubve movieFreee
    onlin iteractive puasy gamesPics off menn s cocksAdult online gameAddictesd too boobs torrentKisinger sexBlack stinjk pussyRobn swpboda sexyFreee piture bigg cocksHeer bare assFrree por streeaming oon ipoid touchHoow bbig
    is michae jackson’s dickDownkoad free frree movie pornStrip foosballFree blaack nure moviesCucumber ssex analTangipahyoa sexFordd esxort zx2
    dlor pabel replacementBrow nude teensYung bogs being spahked whipped
    torturedMalee face fuhcked biPopi virginsTjookb portn scenesKerri asem nudeCann milk and papayyas enlarte breastLesgian incest mlther daughter pcsMamasaan thhe
    asianGay gyys asleepPennis pump bbefor aand afterFreee nuse lickrd clipTeenager xxx picsStrips tto mae
    staikrs lesss slipperyFrankenmstein girps wiol swem srrangely sexy – fggot mp3Teeen seex africaPingg ponng sexx show bangkok thailandDbujos pornls de pokemomMale masturbation lessokn videoFreee
    strip tsase nudeDoes myy peniss look normalMexico adullt
    only vacationJerkooff cumshotSilocon breast surgeryFucck of
    the yearGay sumo pornSotrell titsFreee pornn mixTertminal
    facial hir growthBigg hug amaatuer homemade lingerie boobsBoyy penis hairWegcam gaysXhaster
    een boyy fucking oold grannyAian and gul revaluatioln etnFucck herr brains
    out pornRebecfa bkue fucksButtpn ccat doll pussy textSexx voyeur xxxLesbian looking
    manBrowned ground turkey bredast white colorChastity
    belt anhal openingBokworm redheadLingerie stores bca ratonFreee porrn video trailersFreee nud forumsPscho sexualCourt videos
    xxxRachjel ndersby lesbianFreee world ide stle pornPatrcia heaton’s titsKatma
    cuum likoe crayMy frienjds suckCt indepndent escortCoock lickinjg maan oold womanAnticlimaactic sex videdo ofvd9wuaptu42kivtt8s

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: Content is protected !!