S. Kaladevi v. V. R. Somasundaram & Ors.
📌 Court:
Supreme Court of India
Judgment dated: 12 April 2010
🔎 Background Facts
-
The dispute related to immovable property.
-
The plaintiff relied upon an unregistered sale deed to claim rights in the property.
-
The defendant objected to its admissibility under Section 49 of the Registration Act, 1908, arguing that since the document was compulsorily registrable but unregistered, it could not be received in evidence.
The core issue before the Supreme Court was:
❓ Whether an unregistered sale deed can be admitted in evidence for any purpose?
⚖️ Legal Issues
-
Whether an unregistered sale deed affecting immovable property can be admitted in evidence?
-
Whether such document can be used for collateral purposes?
-
Scope of proviso to Section 49 of the Registration Act.
📖 Statutory Provisions Involved
-
Section 17, Registration Act, 1908 – Compulsory registration of documents.
-
Section 49, Registration Act, 1908 – Effect of non-registration.
-
Proviso to Section 49 – Permits use of unregistered document for collateral purposes.
-
Section 53A, Transfer of Property Act (incidentally relevant).
🧑⚖️ Supreme Court Holding
The Supreme Court held:
✅ 1. General Rule:
An unregistered sale deed affecting immovable property cannot:
-
Confer title
-
Create interest in property
-
Be admitted as evidence of ownership
✅ 2. Important Exception (Proviso to Section 49):
Such a document can be admitted in evidence for collateral purposes.
🎯 What is “Collateral Purpose”?
Collateral purpose means:
-
A purpose other than proving transfer of title
-
Something incidental or secondary
Examples:
-
Nature of possession
-
Character of entry
-
Date of transaction
-
Evidence in suit for specific performance
But ❌ Not to prove ownership or complete transfer of property.
🧠 Core Ratio (In Nutshell)
🔹 An unregistered sale deed cannot convey title or prove ownership.
🔹 However, it is admissible in evidence for collateral purposes under the proviso to Section 49 of the Registration Act.
🔹 Courts must distinguish between proving title (not allowed) and proving collateral facts (allowed).
📊 Practical Trial Court Importance
| Issue | Position After This Case |
|---|---|
| Unregistered sale deed | Not proof of title |
| Admissibility | Yes, but limited |
| Collateral use | Permissible |
| Specific performance suit | Can be relied upon |
| Title declaration suit | Cannot prove ownership |
🔥 Why This Judgment is Important
-
Frequently cited in property disputes.
-
Clarifies confusion regarding admissibility vs evidentiary value.
-
Used in Order 7 Rule 11 and objection to exhibit cases.
-
Important in mutation, possession, and injunction matters.
📌 Exam-Oriented One-Line Ratio
“Unregistered sale deed is inadmissible to prove title but admissible for collateral purposes under proviso to Section 49 of the Registration Act.”