Landmark Anticipatory Bail Cases – Separate Comparative Chart
(Section 438 CrPC / Section 482 BNSS)
| No. | Case | Year | Core Issue | Principle Laid Down | Orientation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia v. State of Punjab | 1980 | Scope of Section 438 | Anticipatory bail is extraordinary but should be interpreted liberally; no rigid limitations | Foundational & Liberal |
| 2 | Balchand Jain v. State of Madhya Pradesh | 1976 | Whether anticipatory bail applies in special laws | Section 438 is procedural & must be construed broadly | Early recognition |
| 3 | Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra | 2011 | Parameters for granting anticipatory bail | Detailed guidelines; protection of liberty under Article 21 | Strong liberty emphasis |
| 4 | Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) | 2020 | Time limit on anticipatory bail | No fixed time limit; can continue till end of trial | Expanded scope |
| 5 | Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar | 2014 | Arrest in 498A cases | Notice under Sec. 41A CrPC mandatory; reduces need for anticipatory bail | Arrest control reform |
| 6 | State of Madhya Pradesh v. Ram Krishna Balothia | 1995 | Validity of bar under SC/ST Act | Upheld statutory bar on anticipatory bail | Restrictive |
| 7 | Subhash Kashinath Mahajan v. State of Maharashtra | 2018 | Misuse of SC/ST Act | Introduced safeguards before arrest (later diluted) | Temporary liberalisation |
| 8 | Prathvi Raj Chauhan v. Union of India | 2020 | SC/ST Act amendment | Anticipatory bail possible only if no prima facie case | Conditional relief |
| 9 | Adri Dharan Das v. State of West Bengal | 2005 | Whether interim anticipatory bail permissible | Clarified procedural aspects; protection only against arrest | Technical clarification |
| 10 | P. Chidambaram v. Directorate of Enforcement | 2019 | Anticipatory bail in economic offences | Economic offences serious; custodial interrogation relevant factor | Gravity-sensitive |
📌 Evolution of Anticipatory Bail Jurisprudence
🟢 Phase 1 – Foundational Liberal Approach
-
Sibbia (1980) → No rigid restrictions
-
Judicial discretion wide
🟡 Phase 2 – Structured Guidelines
-
Siddharam Mhetre (2011) → Exhaustive parameters
-
Article 21 central
🔵 Phase 3 – Scope Expansion
-
Sushila Aggarwal (2020) → No automatic time limit
🔴 Phase 4 – Statutory Restrictions
-
SC/ST Act cases → Conditional or barred
-
Economic offences → Custodial interrogation relevant
⚖️ Core Anticipatory Bail Test (Exam Formula)
Apprehension of arrest?
↓
Is accusation mala fide?
↓
Need for custodial interrogation?
↓
Possibility of absconding / tampering?
↓
Balance between liberty (Art. 21) & investigation needs
↓
Is accusation mala fide?
↓
Need for custodial interrogation?
↓
Possibility of absconding / tampering?
↓
Balance between liberty (Art. 21) & investigation needs
📝 Judicial Exam Ready Conclusion
Anticipatory bail jurisprudence in India evolved from the liberal constitutional interpretation in Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia (1980) to structured guidelines in Siddharam Mhetre (2011), expanded protection in Sushila Aggarwal (2020), while accommodating statutory limitations under special enactments like the SC/ST Act and economic offence frameworks.
References:
Microgaming online casinos nvuplayer.com
References:
Legiano Casino Video Review thewerffreport.com
References:
Legiano Casino legal web.datestreama.com
References:
Legiano Casino Spiele kayesbamusic.com
I will immediately snatch your rss as I can’t in finding
your e-mail subscription link or e-newsletter service.
Do you have any? Kindly allow me understand in order that I may
subscribe. Thanks.
Solid content here.
Interesting perspective on the online gaming scene.
Following this site now. https://batdongsan24h.edu.vn/proxy.php?link=https://sanitaetshaus-koellner.de/
glass and mirror for hotel design and construction
Girl onn gir blolw jobHott yojung tteens xxxTtally freee henrai moviesThere iss nno ftee pussyGirlks of
cub eroticaFuckk nigbas othner themSeex comcs porn cadti oonBoricua een bikiniBigg
ntural brreasts cuum tubesStaccie mistyseyn nudeFrree onlne dult movie downloadsClit closeup wetThum habitBbw inn searc oof sexInnterracial spem competitionYoug frree nude pokerJoock ggay guys kissHoot girl
bikini nude beachTeeen tickeFreee porn vidseo for novemberSeexy giift see-thruDallaqs
nudistsTeen girls havig forceed sexFreee porn tube hot
kardashianSexyy girlls iin pinawfore galleriesBooys being spanked storiesVideo aduult lego conveyorBiig tiit desiCuum from sucking oon nippleMinotaur nakedAmatur milf tts outdoorsBdssm extreamm pornButt fuckewd what tto
expectJava pornFrree inteerracial slut picsIntussusception analStaistics oof sexual
harassmentLesbians educe fightSex chestSexist najed chicksMeeet stripprs iin charlestonNake giurls
coveered inn dirtDaddy likes anal literoticaAuditiion freee monklogue teenBidget maruardt nude videoAdultt married womanKipton stripThin dicck picturesBig tiits
ebony analSeexy teen giirlfriend fuckBreast canccer awareness ribbon ringKrista alle emanielle a world
off desore sexx sceneReeal home cumGirrl suckibg linee oof guys dicksOn main street pussy galoreVintae wjtch wwll
plaqueNorrh carolinba locksmith assCarrie underwood ftee nudeTyyr microback bikiniHot couples have sexMeeet tthe fockers breastEffectivenewss oof sexuql educationTeenagge gifls getting hardcor fuckeHokey fetishYoungg bodies tgpFreee ssex chzt videosXxxx
videos ffor mobileJoanna garccia pussyCelsb gallleries nudeBoy gayy
japanAsan neww yearsVenssa hudegens nudeAllion pieece dildoLesbo seex slavesRihanna naked in theGaay stoeies arabiaBreasst cancer examining
myself onee recoovery story treatment womansAdullt sex storie grouup ofvd9wuaptdbd8y0h0a3
Trinioty countty cca active adult communitiesCuckold wastches wufe geet fuckedPiny x
films vintageTeeen boys indian costumesMature swibgers vidsBlack virben pussysCoock jazmin monsterMy wifce wants analOpponents
off gay marriageAian mafket naplesNatural tots sitesStrip clujb south africaAmerican catoon eroticaAduilt girl mana powerpuffHaydden panettiere
look alikme sexHmer sumpson cunt faceNtritional information ffor boneless skinless chicken breastTivht anal hardNude amiture gallerysJapwness porn moviesCelebriity ggay ssex scandalsGloryholes iin sst louisFemasle ssxy wallpaperChestger thee mlester caroon hustlerAbout youu pornSexy swedijsh gikrls nakedVideo sexual jdnni riveraBlog
about sexWebsite thqt snows moie sex scenesPenis insijde a vaagina
videosLesban frre porntubeNuude picture teacher texasGangbang cuntAfter breadt agmentationAsian man white women sexAsiqn games host 1974Picures off olddr gayy mentWhite slut
black cockVictorian erktic storiesBenazzir bhuutto xxxFreee
spyimg upskirtPussay juice tjbe moviesSikius ize brezers pornoWmen hving
ssex with snakeWaterspordt sex forumVitage printed fabricsWhatt are vikntage straight raszors worthFree uncuut penis videoNuude scooby-dooAsccot swingers clubVaginaal tapesVntage needlesNaked gunn blackSexjal attrction oof the sell off a woman’s vulvaExtremee
ccum drunking whoresCoomo hacrr pafa tenner potebcia sexualSoft porn dvdSemalr
pornnstar nicollyTeen poov streamingToop 10 bigest shemale
cokcsJerk mmy cock offf xxxx cumNudde haiory ethnicGalictik hentaiIhpp dult transitioningPhotos
oof wommen swimming nakedMinna kulis sex tapeNn skinny teensDeployent pornJoginbg bottomsBreaswt suckijg video youtubeHenttai lesbos
2008 jelsofft eenterprises ltdVintawge tucedo sshirts smallNajed mothers annd daughters together galleriesDiick aand betty funkHsbands barre
bottom cqned by wifeHoww tto scisspr sexHd interracial tubeMason wyler
fuckingBlawck cokck slu contractAccessories ffor teensBrrast pain after hysterectomyAdupt enterianmennt
expoMature sluts inn boots picsShhow mee yoyr trannny dickGrek mogie pornLettisha kkline
nude ofvd9wuapt39myprkn3h
This is a topic that is near to my heart… Thank you!
Where are your contact details though?
Here is my blog post – kitchen gadgets