Order 7 Rule 11 – Landmark Judgements

Posted on by Admin

Here are the best landmark judgments on Order VII Rule 11 CPC (Rejection of Plaint) with proper citation and crisp judicial summary (exam + trial court useful):

1️⃣ T. Arivandandam v. T.V. Satyapal

Citation: (1977) 4 SCC 467
Bench: Justice V.R. Krishna Iyer

🔹 Ratio:

  • If on a meaningful reading of the plaint, it is manifestly vexatious and meritless, the Court must reject it at the threshold.

  • Trial courts should not permit “clever drafting” to create illusion of cause of action.

  • Power under Order 7 Rule 11 must be exercised activly and promptly.

🔹 Importance:

Foundation case for preventing abuse of process.

2️⃣ Saleem Bhai v. State of Maharashtra

Citation: (2003) 1 SCC 557

🔹 Ratio:

  • While deciding application under Order 7 Rule 11:
    ✔ Only plaint averments are to be seen
    ❌ Written statement is irrelevant

  • The power can be exercised at any stage of the suit.

🔹 Importance:

Clarified scope of scrutiny.

3️⃣ Dahiben v. Arvindbhai Kalyanji Bhanusali

Citation: (2020) 7 SCC 366

🔹 Ratio:

  • If suit is barred by limitation from plaint itself, rejection is mandatory.

  • Courts must examine whether plaint discloses:

    • Real cause of action

    • Or merely illusory statements

  • Clever drafting cannot save barred suit.

🔹 Importance:

Modern authoritative judgment (frequently cited in Gujarat HC).

4️⃣ Church of Christ Charitable Trust v. Ponniamman Educational Trust

Citation: (2012) 8 SCC 706

🔹 Ratio:

  • Cause of action must be clearly disclosed.

  • Absence of material facts = rejection.

  • Partial rejection of plaint is not permissible (whole plaint must go).

5️⃣ Mayar (H.K.) Ltd. v. Owners & Parties, Vessel M.V. Fortune Express

Citation: (2006) 3 SCC 100

🔹 Ratio:

  • Court must assume plaint facts as true.

  • If those facts still do not disclose right to sue → reject.

📌 Quick Judicial Test (Exam Ready)

While deciding Order 7 Rule 11:

  1. Read plaint as a whole

  2. Assume facts true

  3. Ignore defence

  4. Check:

    • Cause of action? (Cl. a)

    • Undervaluation? (Cl. b)

    • Insufficient court fee? (Cl. c)

    • Bar by law (Limitation/Statute)? (Cl. d)

    • Duplicate plaint? (Cl. e & f)

🧑‍⚖️ Most Frequently Cited in Courts Today:

👉 Dahiben (2020)
👉 Saleem Bhai (2003)
👉 T. Arivandandam (1977)

Related Posts

9 thoughts on “Order 7 Rule 11 – Landmark Judgements”

  4. Prettyy ection of content. I jus stumbled
    uplon yur weeb sitre annd inn accession cqpital tto ssert thst I acquite acfually enjkyed acccount yokur
    bllg posts. Anyway I’ll bbe subsribing tto yoiur feeds andd even I achievement yoou axcess
    consistently quickly. ofvd9wuapt6fgh8y9euq

    Reply

  8. Have youu evedr thougvht abbout adding a little biit mire tha juszt yur articles?
    I mean, whaqt yoou say iss vsluable andd all. Nevertheless justt imaqgine iff yyou adde soje ggreat grphics oor
    video clips tto giive your psts more, “pop”! Yourr contet iss
    excellent but wwith piocs andd clips, thiss blog coukd crtainly bee one oof tthe vdry best in itss
    field. Great blog! ofvd9wuaptvxhepgpdev

    Reply

  9. Fcial tisssue holderCumm stijll on heer faceNaughhty
    alysha peeFreee busfy blo jobb movieTeeen fhck cumshotVintage women’s
    vote imageSttar trewck nudeNudist reesorts inn northernInterracil double mpegNudee fleexy
    gymnastsAll porn toonsFuull lenmgth porrn dvvd onjline freeLoong bbig
    clitorisFrsaks off cock glassesTesas association against sexcual
    assaultStockimgs mature pornWotds wwith tiit oor breastPleaszure p lill wayne mp3Offroad
    adult goo kartsDrwn futurazma hentaiCeleb getting nakedFaair iin lindesay lohnan nudde picc vanityBrass breastPenfoldss vintageWager blisters insude bottm lipInterazctive ppay ssex programLargge lohg cuxumber insertiopn vaginaFrree por beest clarityColliuns adult educationShow mee where mmy clit isShoww mee ypur asss holeGandma
    ssex videosTiaa carrder sexyNakwd locker room wokmen photoOldd womasn asianEbonny finger clitFeedd live vodeo xxxSexxy giels wijth ccum
    shotsBig tited moms ggetting fucked freeBbbw dominhatrix
    manhattanSmoling pantyhpse thaiGirls barefoot bondageBlow jobb byy fatt old
    ladiesArre latx matttresses goodAdulkt umbilial hernia recoveryBs fae nudeVagial thrfush infectionSockk
    lesbjan sexRusseia sexx 19Wach mmy stepsiter fuckPortno freepics oof sexy girlsBeaytiful asin gurls drinkjng milkSexxy oioled womenActve adult communities
    iin floridaCosta rica girls nakeed photosWomzn shaved heawd short hair cutTeen twiknks videoAmmry avikation aass off aerica foundationLass vegaas escorts hotel danceOnlne aadult video downloadOrggy anql blow pussyAnnime scenhe sexSexy ebony teensTuregalore sexFreee cite aass ten boysCurryy
    chickoen breastChhad douglas gayBesst mvie sex senes videosAdult star wwrs toonsCuum fioled blogUgly fatt people fuckingSearchh reality pornYohng tigyht asss
    mommiesFucked getting pussy whiteBet college hills virgin islandsBresast tyermography leve 4Hoow too make your penis bikgger with your handActibe dult
    commmunity lenigh valleyTeal caogary escortMannequhin gaay photosFrree asian shemalesexTeeen wolff soundsCllub gllry holeTeednie lesbian por galleriesFreee nuide beyone picsGirlvrend
    thumbsErltic solution netCanccer compatiibility pisces sexualFree homemare porn videoasTaxii handjobsCllub covenry nudeFrree oldet
    granndma porn moviesYoung beunette wuth tiht pussyAvatar lesbian pornHott seexy akan pornFemake humiliiation sluts publicWatch live adult tvv onlineBrwast casncer photographsMilf lingeriie videosLattex hhelp
    commandsBigg tiots bikinis mature partiesSpank thongFreee heibl nudee phottos ofvd9wuaptnuks1fanwc

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: Content is protected !!