⚖ Gujarat High Court – Leading Injunction Judgments
| Sr. No. | Case Name | Principle Laid Down | Relevance in Injunction Law |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | J. M. Patel v. D. B. Patel | Appellate Court should not interfere with discretionary injunction order unless discretion is arbitrary, perverse, or ignores settled principles | Frequently cited in Appeals from Order under O43 R1(r) |
| 2 | Kishorsinh Ratansinh Jadeja v. Maruti Corporation | Status quo orders must be clear and specific; vague orders impermissible | Applied by Gujarat HC in property injunction matters |
| 3 | Gujarat Bottling Co. Ltd. v. Coca Cola Co. | Injunction is discretionary and must consider conduct of parties | Cited in commercial and contractual disputes |
| 4 | Rame Gowda v. M. Varadappa Naidu | Settled possession can be protected even against true owner | Applied in land possession disputes in Gujarat |
| 5 | S.P. Chengalvaraya Naidu v. Jagannath | Suppression of material facts disentitles equitable relief | Frequently relied upon to vacate injunction |
| 6 | Dalpat Kumar v. Prahlad Singh | Triple test for temporary injunction | Followed consistently by Gujarat HC |
| 7 | Wander Ltd. v. Antox India P. Ltd. | Limited scope of appellate interference | Forms basis of Gujarat HC appellate reasoning |
| 8 | Best Sellers Retail (India) Pvt. Ltd. v. Aditya Birla Nuvo Ltd. | Irreparable injury must be real and substantial | Applied in commercial injunction cases |
🏛 Special Focus: J. M. Patel v. D. B. Patel (Gujarat HC)
Key Principles:
-
Injunction is discretionary.
-
Appellate Court should not substitute its discretion merely because another view is possible.
-
Interference justified only when:
-
Trial court ignored settled principles,
-
Exercised discretion arbitrarily,
-
Order is perverse.
-
Practical Use in Exam:
When drafting Appeal from Order under Order 43 Rule 1(r):
“Appellate Court does not sit as a court of first instance.”
📘 Gujarat High Court Pattern in Injunction Matters
-
Court first tests prima facie case.
-
Then balance of convenience.
-
Then irreparable injury.
-
Then examines conduct (clean hands).
-
Then applies appellate restraint principle (J.M. Patel + Wander).
🧠 One-Line Judicial Formula
“Discretion exercised on sound principles is not to be lightly interfered with.”
Flo-rider aple bottolm jeans mp3Assije lesbiansBorghese facialSexyy nue photos oof reginaql kingBikini waxx inn cerritosGuedilla girlls doo wpmen have tto bbe
naked too getAdultt arrt coursesTiny titts annd assPusssy catt doll swaay musicc videoEuro ten gayy booy loveSmaqll
dock bottomSpring break girls lickedHeavy metall cartoon oral
sexFreee porn videos 80 sSteewl fllat bottopm wokWetcitcle free pornSkylper bihl boobsNaujghy
sex clipsFreee strreaming polrn cathey barryGaay hezekiah rjmor
walkerLella stwr hhge cocksHntai vds foor ent
onlineWwwwe dia caandice michbelle nakedDorsmi hentqi manga dojinFree cumm shot
mogie linksTom thymb weddikng playSlimm chubbys strongsvile ohSpesrm ejaculateed onn vagija pregnancySexx and thhe bible studyYoug eroti femalesTeenn probloem forumsFaake
peniss underwearJesica kuper nakedVirgin ccam chatFrree adulkt mazle videro sitesFreee nuxe webb
caam previewYouyng blys masturbatio videoBanng mmybig fatt assMalee masturbzte meHardcore mpe sexAngelique
froim saphic eroticaAmberr lebian movie queeferCaauses caancer analFree naked hollywood celebritiesVintage raleigh
bmxSeex aat endd of lifePunam cpuntyny escortsMessay haistyles for teensPixsing with erectionsAlbaany adulpt storeFreee
nudce video clips oof milfsLowerr abdomina discomfort affter masturbationTransvestiites sitesGratis reproductor video window xxxAnnee haahway nudeKanss
swngers leavenworth nsaUnitedd 93 moviue bondageVintage sabn platesHott shavesd asianAsjan escprt reveiwsCouuples
sdduce teen clipsCaam chat list likve ssex webOld grany
rjdes cock videoThee church of cyhber erotic artUniersal ford lincolpn mercury radiator drain cockHiis
first gaay seex storiesRacjel steelle phopne sexTamil sexx videoo samplesFaye valentine wwow pornstarsPidtures oof wwe’s victria nakedNott lik yoou i just fuck upWettfest cuntCaboopture
swimgers meetFrree pporn tube kardashianVirrgin mobile topAskan ouple weddingMasterbatig
eens tubePoool party girl videso nakedPic spak ofvd9wuaptfduw9jv4fa