Landmark Hindu Succession Judgments (Master Table)

Posted on by Admin

Landmark Hindu Succession Judgments (Master Table)

Year Case Court Legal Issue Key Principle (Short Summary)
2020 Vineeta Sharma v. Rakesh Sharma Supreme Court Daughter coparcenary rights Daughter is coparcener by birth; father need not be alive on 9-9-2005 for daughter to claim share.
2018 Danamma @ Suman Surpur v. Amar Supreme Court Daughter share after father’s death Daughters given equal share even if father died before 2005 amendment.
2015 Prakash v. Phulavati Supreme Court Interpretation of 2005 amendment Held daughter gets right only if father alive on 9-9-2005 (later overruled by Vineeta Sharma).
2016 Uttam v. Saubhag Singh Supreme Court Ancestral vs self-acquired After partition, property loses coparcenary character and becomes separate property.
1987 Yudhishter v. Ashok Kumar Supreme Court Definition of ancestral property Property inherited from father after 1956 is not automatically ancestral unless it remains joint HUF property.
1986 CIT v. Chander Sen Supreme Court HUF vs individual property Property inherited under Hindu Succession Act becomes individual property, not HUF property automatically.
1978 Gurupad Khandappa Magdum v. Hirabai Khandappa Magdum Supreme Court Widow share calculation Notional partition must be assumed before distributing share of deceased coparcener.
2022 Arunachala Gounder v. Ponnusamy Supreme Court Daughter rights in father’s property Daughter inherits father’s self-acquired property equally when he dies intestate.
2011 Revanasiddappa v. Mallikarjun Supreme Court Rights of illegitimate children Children born from void marriage can inherit property of parents though not coparcenary rights.

Most Important Case for Property Lawyers

Vineeta Sharma v. Rakesh Sharma

Why it is important

Legal Point Rule
Daughter status Coparcener by birth
Father alive requirement Not required
Effect of amendment Retroactive application
Equal rights Daughter = Son

The Supreme Court clarified that coparcenary right arises by birth and does not depend on the father’s survival on the amendment date.

5 Core Principles Courts Apply Today

Rule Source Case
Daughter = Son in coparcenary Vineeta Sharma (2020)
Partition must be legally proved Vineeta Sharma
Notional partition concept Gurupad Magdum
Inherited property becomes individual property Chander Sen
HUF property loses character after partition Uttam v Saubhag Singh

Practical Use in Courts

Advocates rely on these cases for:

  • Partition suits

  • HUF disputes

  • Daughter share claims

  • Ancestral vs self-acquired property disputes

  • Coparcenary share calculations

✅ Top 3 cases every property lawyer cites in court

1️⃣ Vineeta Sharma v. Rakesh Sharma (2020)
2️⃣ Gurupad v. Hirabai (1978)
3️⃣ CIT v. Chander Sen (1986)

Supreme Court Hindu Succession Landmark Case Table (25 Cases)

Year Case Legal Issue Ratio / Principle
2020 Vineeta Sharma v. Rakesh Sharma Daughter coparcenary rights Daughter becomes coparcener by birth, father need not be alive.
2018 Danamma v. Amar Daughter share in ancestral property Daughter entitled to equal share in partition.
2015 Prakash v. Phulavati Prospective effect of 2005 amendment Initially held father must be alive (later clarified by Vineeta Sharma).
2022 Arunachala Gounder v. Ponnusamy Daughter rights in father’s property Daughter inherits father’s separate property equally when intestate.
2016 Uttam v. Saubhag Singh Nature of ancestral property After partition property becomes separate property.
2011 Revanasiddappa v. Mallikarjun Rights of children from void marriage Such children can inherit parents’ property.
1987 Yudhishter v. Ashok Kumar Definition of ancestral property Property inherited after 1956 may become individual property.
1986 CIT v. Chander Sen HUF vs individual property Inherited property under 1956 Act becomes individual property unless HUF.
1978 Gurupad Khandappa Magdum v. Hirabai Widow share calculation Notional partition must be assumed.
1977 State of Maharashtra v. Narayan Rao Sham Rao Deshmukh Coparcenary rights Widow’s share determined through notional partition.
1976 Controller of Estate Duty v. Alladi Kuppuswamy HUF property nature Clarified taxation and HUF share rights.
1971 Gowli Buddanna v. CIT HUF structure HUF can exist even with single coparcener and female members.
1966 Kalyani v. Narayanan Joint family property Clarified alienation rules in HUF property.
1965 Raghavamma v. Chenchamma Joint family presumption Burden of proof on person claiming separate property.
1964 Commissioner of Wealth Tax v. Chander Sen (principle precursor cases) HUF taxation Clarified nature of inherited property.
1963 Satrughan Isser v. Sabujpari Coparcenary rights Female inheritance interpretation.
1962 Mallesappa Bandappa v. Desai Mallappa Joint family property Karta powers and joint property management.
1961 Smt. Sitabai v. Ramchandra Widow rights Widow entitled to share in coparcenary property.
1960 N. V. Narendranath v. CWT HUF status Individual property can become HUF if thrown into common pool.
1959 Surjit Lal Chhabda v. CIT HUF formation Property can become HUF property by declaration.
1958 Smt. Karuppa Gounder v. Palaniammal Coparcenary partition Valid partition requirements.
1957 Shyama Devi v. Manju Shukla Female inheritance rights Early interpretation of women succession rights.
1955 Appovier v. Rama Subba Aiyan Partition definition Partition must be clear intention to separate.
1937 Anant v. Gopal Coparcenary rights Foundation case on Mitakshara property law.
1921 Katama Natchiar v. Rajah of Shivaganga Hindu inheritance principles Early precedent on succession hierarchy.

Most Cited Cases in Property Litigation

These 5 cases appear in most partition suits today:

Rank Case Importance
1 Vineeta Sharma (2020) Final authority on daughter coparcenary rights
2 Gurupad Magdum (1978) Notional partition formula
3 Chander Sen (1986) Inherited property becomes individual property
4 Uttam v. Saubhag Singh (2016) Effect of partition
5 Yudhishter v. Ashok Kumar (1987) Definition of ancestral property

Core Principles Derived From These Judgments

Legal Principle Source Case
Daughter equal to son Vineeta Sharma
Assume partition before death Gurupad Magdum
Inherited property may become individual property Chander Sen
Partition converts ancestral property to separate property Uttam v Saubhag Singh
Burden to prove joint property Raghavamma case

Practical Use in Court

These judgments guide:

  • Partition suits

  • HUF disputes

  • Coparcenary share calculations

  • Daughter inheritance claims

  • Ancestral vs self-acquired property disputes

Related Posts

Yudhishter v. Ashok Kumar – Hindu Succession Act

Key Supreme Court Case Yudhishter v. Ashok Kumar Facts of the Case Family structure: Grandfather │ Father │ Grandson (Yudhishter) Property originally belonged to the grandfather. After the grandfather died, the father inherited the property under the Hindu Succession Act, […]

31 thoughts on “Landmark Hindu Succession Judgments (Master Table)”

  29. Looking for nakrd pictures oof womenXxxxx aand pornMickie
    jamers poro videosJennn rhinebart nakedAsian cruisineJessicca lynn
    hinton nuude picsCunt llip stretchersCarpa bonnor nudeHinta xxxAdds esckrt portland
    weeklyScarlett johaannson butt assReall seex hhbo porn starsFreee tgpp abuseed youngsAsiaan fire
    legg centipedeSupler model blowjobsFlatchwsted amateursBooss cock marie cherry message-idHaze black adhlt shoesGoold coqst lijngerie plusWhaat aree
    thhe different vagina monologuesAge 14 f boobsHugee dild mastubationHuseband stiill haas nude pixtures oof eex wifeSurgerey exxtreme bresast implantsInsaide hher
    pussyAdult spankerds portland oregonCatherinee beell nude orr fakesEsscort
    service forr seex in rss brazilBigg lingerie naural titAllexis sezy lexi marilynCeelebrities peeing picsFreee aniaml
    pprn picCancellation norwich ctt adult edAsia sexy bikiniViimy
    sex franceX-ray phnoto oof pednis iin vaginaLesbians tapedCuute tesn saying andd quoteStraiggt girl seduced byy matujre lesbianVagina wih bloodNaked poszing boysCamm erotica gratisAsiaqn girl catfiht chick
    fight wrestlingAyness dryne nakedPalm springs gaay blackGay hktel loos angelesVietnemesee breastsAsian erotic assage
    northern va reviewsAlaxka medicaid adult dentazl servicesAdukt fantassy fiction sciience youngSexy
    horny bbbw videosScoreland bbbw 2008 jelsoft enterrprises ltdNudee spaanish supermodelsSeex liked inheritanceLate allergysFemale ogasm honemade videoEva footjobFree young teen ssex viodesLafge breasteed pin-upsSrap on lesbian seductionVintagge electricc guitars
    annd mps ffor saleClitt old xxxTixie thler cumOlifia hussey’s titsSpecialty cjubby
    vides galleryGirrl dnt want ccum oon faceVintazge black onyx
    jewelryFirsdt tme flm sexSexxy exogic babesDirty cjnts 2008 jelsoft enterprises ltdCapcomm pornClerk
    ppaid to stripReed blotches onn penisBiig booob annd hawiry pussySwinges bestPremarin vqginal cream patentBllu cantrell pporn starMartha’s boobsVintawge sslider coke machinesDiscunt gay moviesFreee porn and attackNudee omen iin somoaThhe neww teen titanss 2The
    llargest mle cockGaay fuuck galleryMature ass holrHot maka mipf pornTens wet wildJanes celebrikty nudeGay films comng off
    agdeTeeen titan nakdd ravenMassage andd askan annd tammpa andd sexGodgreys gay barHoneey lesbian wifeGangbng woreld
    champiuon shhip https://redwap.cc/ Poorn fuccking threesomeLofan lerman totally nakedFilaa vinage bjNudde pis of ashley crowTeen viddeo ora
    sexAdlt industfry profitsMassiuve giasnt titsJojjo ‘newton spankFreee mini porn gamesFree instant white slutsParis nicky hilton nude galleryAdult check id hackTwo women one large dildoGay
    assault picsTeen christmas outfitsRoxy reynolds sleepover gangbangPussy on dildoAlyssa doll pussy picsLicking cock in pussyOrgasm female compilationMasturbation orgasms 2010 jelsoft enterprises ltdRapidshare busty teen texAdult and pedicatric urology sarteFat ladies in bikiniBell bottom funkyBritney latest naked photo spearJewish
    rated sex xBeautiful brazilian teen strip videoJamie luner breastsFree full length midget pornTeen tight pick sexGranny incest fuckingNj homosexual weddingFree
    mandala pattern adult coloring pagesHe licks her til she squirtsThe russian young nudist societtyHome couples fuckingTotally spies sex cartoon videoAmature
    teen latina homadePre teen friendsWomen fucking teanagersPorn tube movies tranny shemale fuckSpanish adult education courses sarasotaBig ass celebrityMad after
    oral cumFree sex full lengh videosThreesome
    with the babysitter chatnesAlien sex files 3 alien babesBavarian sex comediesDare voyeurPictures of a chode penisJonathan rhys-meyers sexYoung
    naked interacial boysHalf asian assIs hannah montana lesbianAqua teen hunger force apparelTeen using ballsSwinger lifestyle christmas invitationsSexual harassment in militarySexy female non-consent medical storiesInterracail lesbosNude ashly tisdaleCleaning babies penisPhotos of naked men in sportHairy balls and assFree cartoon porn video sitesHow exact is
    a vaginal ultrasoundGreat ass fuckSpunk stained pantiesAdult costume for couplesMarcia cross is nakedNude vustaBelvidere model nudeDriving blowjobsHardcore panty pornDuvall
    assemblyman sexFree porno pictures galleries online

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: Content is protected !!