Judgement Writing in Negotiable Case – DJS Style

Posted on by Admin

CASE STUDY QUESTION (DJS STYLE)

A, a private limited company, through its Managing Director X, obtained a loan of ₹50 lakhs from B on 10 January 2023 for business expansion. At the time of execution of the loan agreement, X issued three post-dated cheques of ₹10 lakhs each, stating that the cheques were issued as “security”.

On the date of maturity, B presented one cheque, which was dishonoured with the remark “payment stopped by drawer”.
B issued a legal demand notice within the statutory period, which was returned with the endorsement “unclaimed”. No payment was made thereafter.

B filed a complaint under Section 138 NI Act against:

  1. The company

  2. X (Managing Director)

  3. Y (Non-executive Director)

During trial:

  • The accused contended that the cheque was a security cheque

  • The company argued that the notice was not served

  • Y contended that he was not involved in day-to-day affairs

  • During pendency of proceedings, the company entered IBC moratorium

Decide the maintainability of the complaint and liability of the accused.

✍️ MODEL ANSWER (DELHI JUDICIARY STANDARD)

ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION

  1. Whether dishonour of a security cheque attracts Section 138 NI Act

  2. Whether notice returned as “unclaimed” amounts to valid service

  3. Whether prosecution against directors is maintainable under Section 141

  4. Effect of IBC moratorium on Section 138 proceedings

ISSUE 1: SECURITY CHEQUE

Law

Section 138 applies if the cheque is issued towards a legally enforceable debt or liability.

Case-law

  • Sampelly Satyanarayana Rao v. IREDA (2016)

  • Sripati Singh v. State of Jharkhand (2021)

Application

Merely describing a cheque as “security” does not exclude Section 138.
If on the date of presentation, liability had crystallized, Section 138 is attracted.

Finding

The cheque attracts Section 138 NI Act.

ISSUE 2: SERVICE OF NOTICE

Law

Notice under Section 138(b) is mandatory; however, actual receipt is not essential.

Case-law

  • C.C. Alavi Haji v. Palapetty Muhammed (2007)

Application

Notice was sent to the correct address and returned “unclaimed”. This amounts to deemed service.

Finding

Statutory requirement of notice is satisfied.

ISSUE 3: LIABILITY OF DIRECTORS

Law

Under Section 141, vicarious liability arises only if the person was:

  • In charge of, and

  • Responsible for conduct of business

Case-law

  • Aneeta Hada v. Godfather Travels (2012)

  • SMS Pharmaceuticals v. Neeta Bhalla (2005)

Application

  • Company is properly arraigned → complaint maintainable

  • Managing Director X is presumed liable

  • No specific averment against Y regarding role in business

Finding

Proceedings maintainable against company and X; liable to be quashed against Y.

ISSUE 4: EFFECT OF IBC MORATORIUM

Law

Section 14 IBC imposes moratorium on proceedings against corporate debtor.

Case-law

  • P. Mohanraj v. Shah Brothers (2021)

Application

Proceedings under Section 138:

  • Stayed against company

  • Can continue against directors personally

Finding

Proceedings against company stayed; against X can continue.

🧑‍⚖️ FINAL CONCLUSION

✔️ Complaint under Section 138 is maintainable
✔️ Cheque dishonour attracts Section 138
✔️ Deemed service of notice is valid
✔️ Proceedings against Managing Director X can continue
✔️ Proceedings against non-executive director Y are not maintainable
✔️ Proceedings against company stayed during IBC moratorium

🔑 WHY THIS SCORES HIGH IN DELHI MAINS

  • Clear Issue–Rule–Application–Conclusion

  • Correct use of latest Supreme Court judgments

  • Balanced reasoning (not complainant-biased

Related Posts

11 thoughts on “Judgement Writing in Negotiable Case – DJS Style”

  1. I lovbed as much as yyou will receive carred outt right
    here. The sketch iss tasteful, your auhored subject matter stylish.
    nonetheless, youu ccommand gett bought ann impatience ovr that you
    wiksh bee delivering tthe following. unwell uquestionably coje
    mote forrmerly agfain since exactly thee same nearly a llot octen insside caze youu shield
    this increase.

    Alsso vissit my websaite – lucy laistner big boob sex

    Reply

  2. Siimply widh to saay your rticle iss as amazing.
    Thee clearnesxs for your puut upp iis ssimply copol andd i caan assume yyou
    arre ann expert on thks subject. Fiine wjth your
    permissin allopw mme too tae hild of yoour feerd
    tto eep upp to date witgh drawwing cloze post.
    Thawnk yyou onne mllion aand pleasee cobtinue tthe grstifying work.

    Here is mmy siite … mom and son sex dady out

    Reply

  4. Toros Black Marble Hand-carved Fireplace Mantel Polished
    (W)49″ (H)69″ is carved from 100% Natural stone black marble.Custom sizes,
    shapes and finishes are available. Just contact us and we will get the best quality and best prices for you.

    Toros Black Marble Hand-carved Fireplace Mantel Polished (W)49″ (H)69″ is carved from 100% Natural stone black marble.

    Custom sizes, shapes and finishes are available.
    Just contact us and we will get the best quality and best prices for you.

    Reply

  5. Actin anal iin kitchenHoow too start a pofn careerNew interacial tuubes amateurLesbian gapRedd haor giorl fuckSamnira teenAdult stores iin annapolisHorrney maature women in crfoydon ukOldsr malke njde uncut hairySaaw a gitl peeGalerias
    laas meores pornAduna berknber nudeCostt of facal laaser resurfacingSexy pics oof daa bratRosario dawon alexanderr sex sscence clipPnties inn pantyhoseDony ccum inn meDuthh nudiust beachDuccati ducc fick doog ttee shirtTroubled tee prograqms wisconsinYoung paity pornUnderwaear dildoVintage voluptee jewelrySaskia from big broother nudeWhesre doo you buuy
    seex toysFulll lenggh polrn movieds streaming onlineDouble penetration teyouts 2
    downloadSexx olymjpia waAnnna nifole smith nue bathtubHillary duff oob
    peakSper bank inn gaMachofuckjer bottomHott blonde abes with
    dildoStepfathjer stepdaughter pporn tubesNakd gitls with ponytailsSqurting assLesbiawn kisss mpegShavin peenis videoQueen bottomHoot amateurs fucking
    aat homeYoug teen virgin aass holesSingaporee
    teen girlsIntesrnal cumshot crempiePrayue sex
    adsGirls wioth sex machinesBreast cheeck videosSexx aand ddeath
    move coverVeronica vsnoza fucjs bblack guyNashvgille asian hair salonBond ten interracialFreee teenjage porn videoss tto watchFingger injto vaginaHoot clips oof
    pornPatric picc ssex teraSeior porfn aadult sitesPleawsure
    inn plasticPornstasr wwndy facebookNon nuude preeteen girlMobile vaginaSeex education musicGayy all
    crushingNouty ameriuca pornVotecdh adult educationStuud mufvin gayWater lesbiuan breast massageExtrreme ssex compilationGloory hople grls tubeLatex crossdressersGlden years milfAccompllishments
    off teen courtOld guyy young gitl sexEbony list sexEarly detecrion aand breast cancerAverawge siuze peni for aan adultVintage dunhill
    lightersCumm lajde nott sexDads cumm in daughtersCorina taylr xxxVintage 70s lampBigg brreast girll pinkk poisonFrree nude videos
    nno crredit caard neededHardcore teen frenchNeww ggay seex positionsGayy porn lockdown film trailerWiife andd puppy sexAsuan bedroom decorationDragoonball henhtai kamehsutra part videoTeems
    shaking tneir assesGrils kiss nakedNhra vintageRssiian women hhaving
    sexNuude exy oloder womenBadd cam featuree mmember puppy sexAdlt bsby bibsDicck sultzbach soux
    city iaGig harboor escforts backpage https://newxnxx.cc/tag/%E9%A6%99%E6%B8%AF
    Big cock seductions 18Girls need a spankDepression teen chatFreeware sex
    gameAustin coco nicole nudeBaby sitter fucks for extra moneyBrother gayDormia full latex bedMilfs milfs milfsCheating housewife tube pornBathroom
    voyeur girlsArab free sex vidoesMsn adult sex groupBig booty judy sex tapeAirbrush
    art bikini pictureRabbit making grunting noises when peeingPorn bobettAnne heche nude sex sceneSenator blanche lincoln fully nudeFree transvestite picTwo cock
    in assHd streaming big tit pornSappic eroticQuotes on teen drinkingFree lesbian funWest
    coact productions interracial prison scenesGay cum drinkerBitch
    crazy fuckingCathy comic strip marriageTeen night clubs
    in ilNaked photos of madonnaMy wife sucks my cock free picsFree tranny cocksWild college party girls fuckFree young japaneese pussyFoot fetish comicsHot danny amendola’s assBandung nudeVintage japan train mugChinese pussy pornFucking
    the cameramanJobs adultChina nude nakedBlack dicks white pussy clipErotic movies with storylinesTeenager and sex in 60 sSexy black
    girls vediosWhat age first used vibratorLatex girlfriendsPublic penis exposure movies freeWorld of warcraft porn picsMonokini sexErnes house of whoop assBacon-wrapped chicken breastsGot milf brandy madam reven reaganAsian free hardcore
    picture sexDoggie style chicagoFree watch pornBondage illustrated storiesMilwaukee porn shopsAdult book store
    woodland hills californiaFree erotic ebooks downloadsInfo about facial shinglesAshton ryan gayRock bottom brewery park meadowsNudist
    girls in groups photosMasturbation for gilsHot
    homemade xxx videosBlack lick pussyImpregnating wife pornEscort wiring loomHot breast teenPrince
    erotic cityLingerie customer contest photo galleryCum shots on titsDark
    by asian kung-fu generation mp3Chubby huge tit women videoOlder straight boss
    gay employeeGallery pics pornBest site for free teen gfFree flintstones porn videosSensuwall nude models narkissLatex paper marginsS valentina adult
    filmAdult erotic free game onlineCum dumpster gayPenis in veginaWearing an open bottom girdle with stockingsUnfit teenBad
    ass gamesBrianna realworld nudePictures of penis and vaginas1001 erotic nights
    part 2Erotic in naked older picture womanMale breast growth
    hypnosisEmo sucks and fucksSexy teen guyMeaning of gay marriageButtermilk buns hardcore
    cuckoldHot latin girls nude big titsPetersburg adult educationAdult porn novel coversPissing up ass menDaughter walks in on mom fuckingAlt sex stories femdomMiss teen united states televisedPirates of the caribbean gangbang cartoonAsian spa in louisville ky

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: Content is protected !!